Within Canada’s publicly financed health care system, some physicians and other advocates are promoting delivery models that incorporate increasing pro-market elements including privatization, investor-ownership, commodification, commercialization, and profit beyond the provincially-approved fee schedules. Variants of these models already exist in Canada, and more are developing.
Provincial and territorial health policymakers are challenged to ensure that service capacity is sustainable, and that it meets the health care needs of Canadians. Policymakers are grappling with the questions of whether it matters who delivers health care, and whether private for-profit delivery should be allowed, even encouraged, within the public system. A framework for approaching these questions in a way that is transparent, thoughtful, and evidence-based is long overdue. Canadian Doctors for Medicare developed the following resources to support this process.
The Health Care Delivery Assessment Tool (HDAT) provides a systematic, criteria-based approach to assessing any proposed innovation within the publicly financed system. The tool assesses proposed innovations based on four sets of criteria with the following focuses:
- Equitable access
- High-quality care
- Effective, clinically indicated services
- Effective integration and system stewardship
At their 2014 General Council, the Canadian Medical Association passed a motion brought forward by CDM to develop and use of an HDAT-like system for health care innovation evaluation. The CMA recognized that in order to assess the impact of models of delivery that are increasingly prevalent in health care transformation, such as stand-alone clinics, community-based care and home care, the Canadian Medical Association requires policy tools capable of assessing and identifying barriers to quality, efficiency and equity in emerging models of health care delivery.
The second resource developed by CDM to assist policy makers with evaluating health care proposals and initiatives is the policy tool kit. This collection of tools will assist Canadian policymakers, the public, and the media in analyzing whether proposed models of market-driven healthcare delivery should be encouraged, regulated, or opposed. We begin with the premise that healthcare should be equitably accessed by all Canadians, regardless of ability to pay, and provide a framework for examining the ways in which private for-profit delivery of publicly financed services might affect that principle.
Read Principles and Toolkit for Assessing Healthcare Delivery Models.
Related Articles/Posts
- A Tool for Assessing Health Care Delivery Models -...Canadian Doctors for Medicare (CDM) is committed to the improvement, and expansion of Canada’s publicly funded health care system. We support the principle...
- The argument for universal health care...November 20, 2010 Re: “Why do we still subsidize care for the well-to-do?” Globe and Mail, November 19, 2010 In Friday’s Globe and Mail Michael Bliss asks why...
- Private clinics could save health system: OMA...October 2, 2011 The Ottawa Citizen Pauline Tam Specialized providers cost less, take stress off hospitals, medical association argues OTTAWA — While Dal...
- We should examine user fees: CMA chief... August 23, 2011 Postmedia News Sharon Kirkey ST. JOHN'S All options should be on the table for financing an overhaul of Canada's health system - includin...
- No. 14: Privatizing Health Care Is Not the Answer:...February 2009 Background From time to time, a compelling analysis of private health care is published in the peer-reviewed literature. Arising out of a lectur...
- OP-ED: Private delivery acceptable when key criter...January 25, 2013 The Medical Post Opinion Editorial by Dr. Danielle Martin Canadian Doctors for Medicare says it opposed Shouldice Hospital sale but not all ...
- OP-ED: Privatizing health care is risky for all of... November 12, 2010 The Globe and Mail By Danielle Martin and Irfan Dhalla In poll after poll, Canadians reaffirm their commitment to a health-care system i...
- No. 40: Do private clinics or expedited fees reduc...June 2013 Koehoorn M, McLeod CB, Fan J, McGrail K, Barer M, Côté P, Hogg-Johnson S. Do private clinics or expedited fees reduce wait- or return-to-work times f...
- No. 19: Great Expectations: The Obama Administrati...July 2009 Background Much is being said about U.S. health care reform, with this year’s election of President Barack Obama. Similar momentum occurred after th...
- Sale of for-profit surgery clinic hits snag, resig...November 4, 2012 National Post Tom Blackwell The unusual saga of a for-profit clinic that does surgery at taxpayer expense took a surprising turn Friday, as ...
- No. 18: The Political Use of Poll Results About Pu...June 2009 Background Where does the public turn for information about private healthcare delivery and funding? Surveys and public opinion polls are a major so...
- OP-ED: The case against Dr. Brian Day’s case ...October 4, 2012 The Medical Post By Dr. Vanessa Brcic For-profit care is not the right direction for the health of all Canadians As many of us are aware, con...
- Learning from Australia's experiment with two-tier...November 25, 2010 Re: “It wouldn’t kill us to look at Australian Health Care” (Jeffrey Simpson, Globe and Mail, November 24, 2010) Jeffrey Simpson thinks that...
- Ontario doctor to leave country after financially-...National Post October 28, 2012 Tom Blackwell Faced with hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt and the prospect of prolonged scrutiny by regulators, an Ont...
- A future that is public … or private? ...March 14, 2013 Vancouver Sun By: Vivian Luk (Special to the Sun) The health care system in British Columbia (and across Canada) is flawed and needs to be i...
- TV: Dr. Danielle Martin makes the case for public ...November 30, 2012 Global TV Dr. Brian Day has a confession to make. He’s a lawbreaker, and he doesn’t care who knows it.“We’re in contravention of the B.C. ...
- OP-ED private health insurance benefits insurance ...December 6, 2010 Penticton Herald By Dr. Khati Hendry I was disappointed to read the guest column from Nadeem Esamil of the Fraser Institute regarding “the t...
- Centric Health gives a pass to Shouldice Hospital ... November 2, 2012 Canadian Healthcare Network TORONTO | The for-profit healthcare company that was poised to buy Shouldice Hospital in Ontario has announced ...
- OP-ED: Shouldice Hospital sale should be rejected...September 17, 2012 Healthydebate.ca By Dr. Irfan Dhalla Last week, the family that owns Shouldice Hospital announced that it would like to sell its facility ...
- Private clinics continue explosive growth...March 28, 2011 CMAJ While skirmishers in the ongoing battle between private and public health care in Canada continue to slug it out through court cases, regu...