April 25, 2013
CBC News
Medical professionals are a raising concerns that a private mobile health clinic offering medical screening services around B.C. is preying on seniors by offering them expensive tests they don't really need.
The American company Mobile Life Screening has been touring the province offering testing packages which include a wide range of medical tests, including ultrasounds and heart and stroke screening for as much as $498.
Eighty-year-old Vern Schnarr told CBC News he went against his doctor's advice and got a scan, even though he's in good shape.
"She thought it was a waste of time, a waste of money and I went against that advice and went and got it done anyways," said Schnarr.
That makes him one of a growing number of British Columbians paying for private screening tests for potential heart disease or stroke
Company spokesman Randy Spielvogel told CBC News the tests provide vascular screenings to otherwise asymptomatic individuals.
"This is something they typically can't get from their doctors since they would have to have symptoms before these tests are ordered. Unfortunately, many patients have no symptoms prior to a stroke or ruptured abdominal aneurysm," Spielvogel said in an emailed statement.
"We are in no way trying to replace any testing that gets done in a hospital. We are simply a screening program. Testing is performed by ARDMS registered ultrasound technologists and interpreted by B.C. licensed physicians."
Doctors raise concerns
While the screening tests are not medically necessary, they are allowed under B.C.'s Health Act.
Nevertheless they are drawing criticism from those inside the public healthcare system like Reid Johnson, the president of the Health Sciences Association of British Columbia.
"This is going to further put pressure on the public system as the worried want to find out what is going on," said Johnson.
Other doctors agree. Dr. Vanessa Brcic, spokeswoman for Canadian Doctors for Medicare, says the private screening service preys on the elderly.
"That is the most vulnerable population they are targeting. It is people in old age homes, because of their age and health status they are suffering."
She also argues private screening makes people think their doctors aren't giving them the whole truth.
"It almost gives them the message that there is something that they are not getting from your family doctor, that this is something else they need, or it is giving them the false hope that if you just get this test you will live longer."
Related Articles/Posts
- No. 26: Increased Ambulatory Care Copayments and H...February 2010 Backgound User fees, extra charges, copayments and the like, resembling zombies which refuse to die, continually re-emerge as tools meant to cur...
- Blood plasma clinics a sign of privatization in he...March 13, 2013 Toronto Star By: Theresa Boyle A group of doctors concerned about increasing privatization in Canada’s health-care system has added its voice ...
- Don't allow for-profit blood clinics, say doctors...March 12, 2013 TORONTO - A controversial and secretive new move by the federal government to approve for-profit blood plasma donation services that pays donors...
- Stop for-profit blood clinics, doctors urge ...March 13, 2013 CBC News Introducing a paid-donor system for blood products could compromise Canada's blood supply and is not justified, a group of physicians ...
- Doctors want more answers about for-profit blood p...March 14, 2013 CTV News The federal government is considering approval for three new clinics in Ontario that would pay donors who give blood plasma. But a key...
- Paying for blood plasma raises new questions ...April 25, 2013 CBC News By: Kelly Crowe Health Canada says private clinics may pay donors for plasma, but critics wonder what is behind the push for a major...
- Should federal and provincial regulators allow pla...April 12, 2013 Toronto Star By: Isabel Teotonio The donation clinic sits empty. Reclining chairs await donors willing to roll up their sleeves for $20. State...
- A future that is public … or private? ...March 14, 2013 Vancouver Sun By: Vivian Luk (Special to the Sun) The health care system in British Columbia (and across Canada) is flawed and needs to be i...
- Health care constraints...November 11, 2010 The Globe and Mail Re: Nobody Should Profit From Health Care? Get Real – Globe and Mail, November 10, 2010 Karen Selick mixes up individual...
- Should we pay for blood? ...April 15, 2013 Maclean's By: Anne Kingston On March 11, federal Health Minister Leona Aglukkaq took to Twitter to issue her first public response to media re...
- For-profit Health Care...
- OP-ED: The case against Dr. Brian Day’s case ...October 4, 2012 The Medical Post By Dr. Vanessa Brcic For-profit care is not the right direction for the health of all Canadians As many of us are aware, con...
- Stop extra billing, picketers urge private Vancouv...August 20, 2012 CBC News A group of doctors and health care advocates protested outside a private health clinic in Vancouver Monday, demanding the clinic stop...
- B.C. health clinic slapped for private billing vow...July 19, 2012 Winnipeg Free Press Kevin Drews VANCOUVER - The president of a health clinic in British Columbia is vowing to continue his legal fight to allow...
- Ontario doctor to leave country after financially-...National Post October 28, 2012 Tom Blackwell Faced with hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt and the prospect of prolonged scrutiny by regulators, an Ont...
- TV: Dr. Danielle Martin makes the case for public ...November 30, 2012 Global TV Dr. Brian Day has a confession to make. He’s a lawbreaker, and he doesn’t care who knows it.“We’re in contravention of the B.C. ...
- Doctors protest private clinic as deadline to stop...August 20, 2012 Vancouver Sun Jeremy Nuttall VANCOUVER — The provincial government will be soon be stepping up its campaign to bar extra billing at a well-kn...
- CDM releases video: Why doctors care about Pharmac...August 7, 2013 VIDEO: Why doctors care about Pharmacare TORONTO – Doctors are adding their voices to the growing call for a national Pharmacare program with t...
- Pharmacare...
- Rx: National Pharmacare - July 2013...Presented as part of a First Aid Kit for Canadian Health Care at the Council of the Federation July 2013. As physicians, we confront the daily challenge of see...